ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini for IELTS Writing: What They Do Well and What a Criteria-Based Marker Adds
On this page
You can use ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini to prepare for IELTS Writing, and for ideas, explanations and rewrites they are genuinely useful. What none of the maker pages we read says is that an assistant marks Writing against the IELTS band descriptors. IELTS.org says certified examiners mark each task on four criteria, and nothing we read describes an assistant doing that job. This page sets out what an assistant does well, what to ask of it, and where a tool built around the criteria differs.
We make IELTS Mentor AI, the app mentioned at the end of this page. We have tried to be fair. Statements about ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini below come from their makers’ own pages, read on 18 November 2026: OpenAI’s study mode page for ChatGPT, Anthropic’s Claude overview, and Google’s Gemini overview and Canvas help page.
Key takeaways
- ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini are general assistants. Their makers’ pages describe study help, drafting, outlining and editing; OpenAI’s even shows an essay graded against a rubric the student supplies. None mentions IELTS.
- IELTS.org says certified examiners mark each Writing task on four criteria, and Task 2 contributes twice as much as Task 1.
- Use an assistant for ideas, explanations and rewrites, and ask for feedback one criterion at a time against the public descriptors.
- Never paste in an answer you intend to reproduce: IELTS.org says copying from another source is severely penalised.
- Do not take anyone’s word for a band, ours included. The check below takes about ten minutes.
What the makers say their assistants are for
Google’s overview of Gemini says that “if you’re writing a blog post, Gemini can create an outline,” and that you can “get help learning difficult concepts.” Google’s help page for Canvas in the Gemini app says you can “directly edit the text or ask Gemini to help you in the prompt box,” and lists options to select text and ask Gemini to revise it, to use Suggest edits, and to adjust the length or tone of a passage.
Anthropic’s Claude overview says “Ask Claude for more than an answer: mine data, pull information together, or make a first draft.” It also describes edits shown as tracked changes in Word, so that you review them.
OpenAI’s page for study mode in ChatGPT calls it “a new way to study in ChatGPT with step-by-step guidance instead of quick answers”. Its examples include “Prepping for an exam” and one headed “Pre-grade your essay”, with the prompt “Act as my professor and grade my assignment according to the rubric.” The rubric there is the student’s own: the page does not mention IELTS or its band descriptors.
The pattern across these pages is a general assistant that drafts, outlines, edits and helps you learn, and in ChatGPT’s case grades against whatever rubric you give it. None of them mentions IELTS or its band descriptors, and none says an assistant’s grade matches an examiner’s. That is not a hidden flaw. It is simply not what those pages say the products are for. Which features you get depends on your account, region and app version, so check the maker’s own page.
What an assistant does well for IELTS Writing
Several jobs in Writing preparation suit a general assistant better than most tools.
Ideas for Task 2. Many candidates stall on what to say, not on how to say it.
Give me five angles I could take on the question “Some people think children should start school later. To what extent do you agree?”, with one reason and one example for each.
Explaining a grammar or vocabulary point. If you do not see why a sentence is wrong, an assistant can explain it several ways, in your own language if you ask.
Here is a sentence from my Task 1 report: [paste]. Explain in my own language what is wrong, then show the corrected sentence.
Rewriting a sentence or a paragraph. Seeing your idea in a stronger form, with every change named, shows the gap between what you meant and what you wrote.
Rewrite this paragraph more precisely, keeping my ideas exactly as they are. List each word or structure you changed and why.
Practice prompts. It can write you a Task 1 or Task 2 style question on a topic you choose, so you never run out of material.
Notice what none of these asks for: a band score.
What the makers do not claim: marking against the descriptors
IELTS.org says certified examiners assess each Writing task on four criteria: Task Achievement (Task 1) or Task Response (Task 2), Coherence and Cohesion, Lexical Resource, and Grammatical Range and Accuracy. It says the criteria are weighted equally, that Task 2 contributes twice as much as Task 1, and that the result is reported as a whole or half band. The public band descriptors say what each band looks like, criterion by criterion. The full picture is in how the IELTS Writing score is calculated.
Ask an assistant for a band and you will get one, written confidently. But nothing in the maker pages we read describes the assistant as marking against those descriptors, checked against examiner marking, or evaluated on IELTS. The number is an opinion about your essay. It may be sensible, and it may not. You cannot tell which from the number alone, so do not choose your test date by it.
How to use an assistant well for Writing
One criterion at a time. Instead of “mark my essay”, paste the essay and ask:
Look only at Coherence and Cohesion. Using the public IELTS Writing band descriptors, which band does this paragraph most resemble? Quote the descriptor wording you are relying on, then show me one place where my linking or paragraphing weakens the answer.
Then repeat for Lexical Resource, for Grammatical Range and Accuracy, and for Task Achievement or Task Response. A narrow question gives you something you can check against the descriptors yourself.
Check the quoted wording. If an assistant cannot point to descriptor language, or the language it quotes is not in the public document, you have learned how much weight its band deserves.
Never paste in an answer you will reproduce. IELTS.org says copying from another source is severely penalised, and that notes or bullet points are not a connected answer. A memorised model answer is a risk, not a shortcut. Ask an assistant to explain why a model answer works, then write your own response to a different question. The Writing test format guide sets out what IELTS.org says is penalised.
Keep the exam shape in your own hands. The test is 60 minutes and two tasks, about 20 minutes for Task 1 and about 40 for Task 2, with at least 150 and 250 words. A chat has no timer and no pressure. You have to supply both, which is a skill of its own. The same point is made for speaking in our companion post on the Speaking test.
A fair test you can run in about ten minutes
Take one of your own Task 2 essays and run three checks.
Consistency. Paste the same essay into two new chats and ask each for a band with a criterion breakdown. If the numbers differ, you have learned how much weight to give either.
Justification. Ask for the exact descriptor wording behind each criterion, then compare it with the published descriptors.
The record. A few essays later, ask which error you have made most often and how many times. Then check the answer against your own drafts.
Where a tool built around the criteria differs
An assistant is built to help with almost any task. A tool built for IELTS Writing starts from the criteria. IELTS Mentor AI marks Writing on the four official criteria and reports a band range, not a single predicted band, for Task 1 (Academic and General Training) and Task 2, with a Data Accuracy check. It runs on iPhone and Android, and it is not an official IELTS product or a replacement for an examiner or for the real test. The site’s essay checker is a structure check in the browser (word count, paragraphs, a clear position, linking words), not a band, and the roundup of Writing feedback apps compares the options on what each one says about itself.
The honest division of labour
The mistake is not using an assistant for IELTS Writing. It is asking one tool to do two jobs. Use an assistant for the open-ended half: ideas, explanations, rewrites and practice prompts, in your own language when that is faster. Use something built around the criteria for the half that has to be measured: each criterion marked, a range instead of one falsely precise number, and a record you can compare from one essay to the next. Whatever you use, hold any band against the public descriptors, and write the answers in your own words.
Practise this with instant AI feedback
Record your answer in the app and get your grammar, vocabulary, fluency and pronunciation analysed in seconds.
Paid app: what it costs · billing and refunds · support
Frequently asked questions
Can I use ChatGPT to practise IELTS Writing?
Yes, and it is useful for part of the job: ideas for a Task 2 question, explanations of a grammar point, rewrites of a sentence you are unhappy with, and practice prompts. What it is not described as doing is marking your essay against the IELTS Writing descriptors. Use it to learn and to draft, then check the result against the public descriptors yourself.
Can ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini give my essay a band score?
They will give you a number if you ask, but no maker's page we read describes IELTS marking, the band descriptors or a calibrated band. IELTS.org says certified examiners mark each task on four criteria, so a number from an assistant is an opinion about your essay, not a mark. Ask it to quote the descriptor wording behind each criterion, then check that wording yourself.
Is it safe to paste a model answer into an assistant and learn it?
No. IELTS.org says copying from another source is severely penalised, and notes or memorised material do not show your own writing. Ask an assistant to explain why a model answer works, then write your own response to a new question in your own words.
How should I ask an assistant to check my Writing?
One criterion at a time, against the public IELTS Writing band descriptors. Ask it to look only at Coherence and Cohesion, for example, and to quote the descriptor wording for the band it suggests. Then repeat for Lexical Resource, Grammatical Range and Accuracy, and Task Achievement or Task Response.
Should I use an IELTS app or just an assistant for Writing?
Most candidates do best using both for different jobs. An assistant is a patient source of ideas, explanations and rewrites. A tool built around the four criteria is for the part that has to be marked as the exam marks it, and reported as a band range. Neither replaces a certified examiner or the real test.
More from the blog
Your First IELTS Speaking Mock Test: What to Expect
What an IELTS Speaking mock test involves, how to read your first result as a score range and a four-criteria breakdown, and how often to take one after that.
How the IELTS Speaking Cue Card Cycle Works
How the IELTS Speaking Part 2 topic pool is commonly reported to refresh, why leaked question lists are unreliable, and how to prepare by topic family.